Score: 8

"Made me laugh"

submission: 7 days without sleep

date: November 25, 2009

I voted 4.

Score: 4

"Hmmmm"

submission: O Ateu e o Urso

date: November 19, 2009

Guess I need to work on my Portuguese...

Score: 3

"Well... needs some work"

submission: First Real Shoot em Up

date: November 19, 2009

A few things I noticed:
1. You need to erase around the edges of the ships. Black boxes look stupid.
2. Getting hit by enemy fire didn't seem to do anything.
3. The music was a bit annoying.

I'm guessing this is your first game, perhaps even your first Flash (excuse me if I'm wrong). Still, it shows potential. Just spend some more time polishing up and you can probably make some fun stuff! You might also want to make something a bit more original but hey, what is original nowadays?

Score: 7

"I liked it"

submission: Dastardly Professor Emo

date: November 19, 2009

Especially compared to my first Flash, this was awesome! Short, quick, concise. And funny. If it makes me laugh, I'll vote for it to stay. Nice work. Make some more stuff!

Score: 8

"Very good, although lacking in a few areas"

submission: PALADIN episode 5 part 2

date: July 15, 2007

The part of this series that truly stands out, as everyone knows, is the level of animation. You are definitely placing yourself in the high echelon of Flash animators. Going from episodes one through five, it is clearly visible that you have spent a great deal of time not only perfecting the animations you were making, but also improving your skills which, by the end of the series, seemed to have developed ten-fold. For this, I highly respect you for your animation and art skills, both of which vastly surpass my own.

Another thing I liked about this series was the voice acting. Although it started off in the first episode as a little lack-luster, the effort and emotional emphasis was greatly improved by this one. The characters in this final title were very believable and added a great deal of depth to the narrative. Also, along with sound, your choice of music (which I believe you made yourself) was emotion and well composed. For this, I give you much kudos because I, too, enjoy composing scores and evoking certain feelings from your audience memebers is the most difficult thing you can do. You, however, hit the nail on the head. Although the music at some points seemed a little "thin" and lacking substance, it still added a great deal to the animation. The only suggestion I have is that you buy something like Kontakt Gold or the Garritan Personal Orchestra kits for whatever program you are using, if you can. This will add more depth and less MIDI sounding music to your animations.

I don't want to say, "now for the bad side", so I do want to emphasize that no part of this series was "bad", but rather in need of improvments. First off, I am a story-buff. I like narratives that are well constructed and well written. To me, it seems like you made episode one rather quick and with an undeveloped tale, that probably changed during the process of making the animation. Then, capitalizing on the popularity of the first, continued the story in another animation. (Forgive me if I am wrong, of course). Unfortunately, by the end of the series you were building off an already dull story. Cliché (which, no offense, is what this is) is OK, but I think had you planned out the entire series beforehand, you would have created a more interesting and engaging story. The story thoughout the series was very linear, with no shift in the flow of the narrative. What I mean is, in the first episode you learn what the protagonist must do, and through the rest of the episodes he just... does it. There are no obstacles that force him to rethink his position or his mission. <Spoiler> One part, however, that does contradict this is when he is forced to kill his mentor in the last episode <End Spoiler>. I can see lack of depth to the story resulting due to the limitations of Flash and the time you wanted to spend on the animation, so don't take this too harsh. Along with this, some of the dialogue could have been better. While it was voiced well, a few lines were a bit shallow.

As for this final episode, I do agree with many people that the ending was too abrupt and created a very anti-climactic finish, which I am sorry to say, takes a lot away from this series. Our hero got his ass kicked, and in the matter of a second, takes out Rhadiel in one swipe of the blade. We are left with many questions as to what happened and get the feeling that this epic battle built up, but then ran out of steam right before it could have been phenomenal. This could have been due to impatience, or perhaps you wrote it to happen this way. Either way, I feel there could have been much improvement on the ending to this series.

However, all in all, I found this a very fun and entertaining series to watch. You spent a great deal of time on on and I hope you will continue your work on a new series, utilizing the advice that I and all of your other fans have given you. Thanks for bringing this now-classic work to Newgrounds for everyone to enjoy! No matter what people say, you are a great artist and a master at Flash animations. Good luck with your next work. I await it.

Score: 8

"A well made short animation"

submission: Slaughter I

date: June 27, 2007

The say the least, you did a very good job with this. I enjoyed the cinematic approach you took towards the production of this flick and I wouldn't be suprised if you made a storyboard prior to animating. While the graphics (although still better than I can do) could use a bit touching up and some more shading, the sound and ambience of the movie made up for any graphical lack. In terms of the overall content, you probably could have changed the mood of the entire film to more "creepy" two ways, in my opinion:

1. Change to a much darker color palette. I think if you used primarily blues, shades, and some other darker colors the movie would have been much more effective.
2. Somewhat along with the darkness, you might have wanted to make the monster a bit more ambiguous and not shown too much of it; maybye just show a streak of it as it runs between some bushes or something. This would have kept us guessing what it was going to look like and build anticipation.

Still, I enjoyed watching this and strongly encourage you to continue animating. Brush up on your graphics skills and possibly work on some things with a full-out narrative story and I think you can do quite well. Good luck!

Score: 3

"Finish it"

submission: Neji Vs Orochimaru

date: May 23, 2007

Personally, I think it is too short and should not pass the judgement process. Also, the lack of sounds really takes away from the experience of the movie. All in all, it's sub par. It will probably pass, however, because people tend to vote on the first 10 seconds of a submission rather than the whole thing, so congratulations on that. You might want to try making more complete works in the future.

Score: 9

"A miraculous piece of work"

submission: Animator vs. Animation II

date: March 15, 2007

I'm glad to see that you incorporated much more into the animation this time around. Instead of staying in the Flash screen you moved onto the desktop which I found very entertaining. Bringing other icons into the fight was a clever idea and the AIM guy vs. the Chosen One was a great fight.

The animation itself was very well done and I would like to emphasize the said adverb. The animation was smooth and looked excellent. The sound fit the work quite well and I don't think music was needed. Simple sounds from the various programs worked well enough. I found this especially amusing because our desktops are nearly identical. I have the same background and programs including the avast! virus scanner. For that, I found an extra sense of enjoyment because it seemed like it was happening on my own computer!

All in all, great work. While I am not a great fan of sequels, I do think this ranks up with your first Animator vs. Animation installment. You added in plenty of features which kept the originality and plain fun in the animation. Great job and keep up the excellent work!

Score: 3

"I'm disappointed"

submission: New Numa

date: September 8, 2006

I think the fame finally got to you, or something. Numa Numa is just one of those things that has it's time, and the time it has is a finite amount. This lacked the energy, the originality, and just about everything the first one had. Numa was a one time thing and true fans should have known that, not pressured you for another one. Another thing, the song sucked. Video editing was good, but I liked the simplicity of the first.

Sorry, but this just doesn't fly with me.

Score: 10

"Very cool"

submission: Strange Days

date: September 5, 2006

That was probably the best done incorperation of Flash and real time video. It was very original and had a good flow to the "story" that existed in the film. The graphics, although most were lines or just video, were not very expressive in themselves, but they were put together nicely and fit very well. The single thing I did not like about this was that some of the transitions between holding a Flash line in your hand and holding a physical object were very blatent and could be easily seen. If I were you, I would have just animated all the lines and not used any live action objects. Other than that, I have no complaints.

This was very well done and one of the coolest live action + animation Flashes I have seen in a long time. It reminds me of Harold and the Purple Crayon. Nice work!